Iowa teen argues the good argument
 

Seattle Gay News
Mobile Edition
rss: SGN Calendar For Mobile Phones http://sgn.org/rssCalendarMobile.xml



SGN Mobile Front Page

SGN ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT SECTION

MOVIE REVIEWS
CALENDAR
NORTHWEST NEWS CALENDAR
CLASSIFIED

click here to go to the main SGN website

 

posted Friday, December 16, 2011 - Volume 39 Issue 50

Iowa teen argues the good argument
by Leslie Robinson - SGN Contributing Writer

I give Jane Schmidt a world of credit. The Iowa high school student held her own in an exchange with Republican presidential candidate Michele Bachmann. At Schmidt's age, shaking a candidate's hand was enough to make me forget my name.

I grew up in New Hampshire, where, due to the state's first-in-the-nation primary, presidential candidates are as abundant as black flies. I assume the Iowa caucuses mean the Hawkeye State is likewise swarming with presidential wannabes.

These famous and important people are intimidating when you're young, and I couldn't have managed more than reading a question aloud before losing the use of my vocal cords.

Not so Jane Schmidt, on a recent day in the Pizza Ranch restaurant in Waverly, Iowa. The Des Moines Register, which carried an account of the back-and-forth with Bachmann, didn't give Schmidt's age or her year in school, but did say she's the president of Waverly High School's Gay-Straight Alliance, so I'll think of her as a senior.

I'll also take a moment to drop my jaw that Waverly High even has a Gay-Straight Alliance.

Standing amidst a supportive crowd of about 65 people, mostly middle-aged and elderly, Michele Bachmann might've thought she was home free. Then, as a CNN video showed, she and her microphone headed toward the student in the red plaid trooper hat.

Schmidt told Bachmann she was concerned about the lack of government support for the LGBT community. Bachmann replied that the government's job is to protect civil rights. 'We all have the same civil rights,' she concluded. That would've been the moment where I'd have thought to myself, 'There's something wrong with that statement and MY GOD everyone is staring at me.'

Not Schmidt. She responded, 'Then, why can't same-sex couples get married?'

The candidate answered, 'They can get married, but they abide by the same law as everyone else. They can marry a man if they're a woman. Or they can marry a woman if they're a man.'

Now that the country has gotten a peek at Michele Bachmann's husband Marcus, a sizable number of people believe that the woman is speaking from experience here.

Schmidt asked why two men can't marry, and Bachmann answered that's the law. 'So heterosexual couples have a privilege,' responded Schmidt.

She was still being logical, while I'd have long since been carried away on a stretcher.

Straight couples have the same legal opportunity, said Bachmann. 'There is no right to same-sex marriage.'

Except for where she was standing. It escaped Bachmann's notice that same-sex marriage is legal in Iowa.

'So you won't support the LGBT community?' asked the student.

'No, I said that there are no special rights for people based upon your sex practices,' said the congresswoman, who must've been annoyed at God for forcing her to talk about sex with a high school student in front of scads of Iowa senior citizens.

Ella Newell, a junior at the high school, tried to advance the point about privilege before the debate ended with Bachmann repeating that every American can marry, just someone of the opposite sex.

Most of Bachmann's statements received applause, probably as much an attempt to silence the girls as to indicate support. But Schmidt carried on, doggedly and civilly, despite the disapproval of her neighbors, and despite the presence of reporters and cameras.

I hope someone bought her a pizza afterwards. Unless she felt like throwing up.

After the exchange between the high school students and the congresswoman, a young man told Schmidt and Newell that they should 'emulate' Bachmann.

Yes, if Schmidt conforms and turns into an always-feminine Christian soldier she could land a guy like him.

Now I'm sure she felt like throwing up.

Leslie Robinson remembers meeting 1976 presidential candidate Mo Udall and trying not to stare at his glass eye. Email Leslie at lesarobinson@gmail.com, and check out her blog at www.generalgayety.com.



next story
GSA at UW Bothell site addresses anti-Gay slur
------------------------------
SGN EXCLUSIVE: Summary judgment in Verbena case
------------------------------
Gay veteran: 'You can't trust' Mitt Romney
------------------------------
Pro and anti-Gay amendments stripped from Defense Authorization Act
------------------------------
ERW raises over $57,000 at Toasting Equality
------------------------------
Marriage equality activist Ed Watson dies
------------------------------
Remembering Chicago journalist Paul Varnell
------------------------------
Bellingham Lesbian bashes back
------------------------------
IN MEMORIAM: Joseph R. Eisenhauer
May 4, 1944 - December 15, 1999


------------------------------
Jase Daniels, twice discharged under DADT, reinstated in U.S. Navy
------------------------------
Bible benefiting Susan G. Komen Foundation banned by Christian bookstore
------------------------------
Same-sex marriage may boost Gay men's health
------------------------------
Turkish occupied zone in Cyprus legalizes Gay sex
------------------------------
NBA union contract adds 'sexual orientation' to nondiscrimination language
------------------------------
Elizabeth Warren ... at last ... authentic grasp
------------------------------
Iowa teen argues the good argument
------------------------------
BREAKING NEWS
------------------------------
Davawn Robinson jury remains deadlocked
------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------
Utah Family Supports School that Outed Gay Son
------------------------------
AllOut.Org Applauds OHCHR and South African Government for Leadership on Historic UN Report Documenting LGBT Human Rights Violations Worldwide
------------------------------
GOP: Gay-Obsessed Party
------------------------------
President Obama Sent This Letter To A Gay Couple Congratulating Them On Their Marriage
------------------------------
Because After 64 Years Together, Louis Halsey and John Spofford Morgan Finally Got Hitched.
------------------------------
Gay Malaysian Man's Wedding in Ireland Sparks Fury at Home, Government Action
------------------------------
Apply today for this intensive leadership program and an internship with an LGBT-friendly member of Congress.
------------------------------
Will Canadians Wipe Out HIV?
------------------------------
2 women share 1st kiss at US Navy ship's return
------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------

------------------------------
 
search SGN
SERVING SEATTLE AND THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST FOR 36 YEARS!