American Idol sweetheart and outspoken LGBTQ+ advocate, Archuleta shares laughter, music, and the emotional journey of finding his authentic self
David Archuleta saved one of his most meaningful stops for last, wrapping up his Devout book tour in Seattle before a sold-out crowd at Capitol Hill’s beloved Elliott Bay Book Company. The former American Idol runner-up turned LGBTQ+ advocate was greeted by enthusiastic fans eager to hear more about his New York Times best-selling memoir, Devout: Losing My Faith to Find Myself. Having spoken with Archuleta last March about the book and his journey toward self-acceptance, it was especially rewarding to see him sharing that story in person with a Seattle audience.
Archuleta kicked off the evening with a special musical treat. Since Seattle wasn’t included on his upcoming Christmas concert tour, he decided to bring a little seasonal cheer to the bookstore, performing his current holiday single, “Warm Me Up.” After all, what better way to warm up a chilly Seattle evening than with that unmistakable voice? The intimate performance reminded everyone why America fell in love with the then 17-year-old singer nearly two decades ago. But the young man who once made teenage hearts flutter with “Crush” has grown into an artist whose greatest accomplishment may be finding the courage to live authentically.
Following the performance, Archuleta welcomed Queer writer and moderator Aleenah Ansari for an engaging conversation filled with humor, vulnerability, and some surprisingly candid revelations. Ansari began by celebrating the memoir’s success, including its instant New York Times bestseller status and 2026 Goodreads Choice Award nomination for Best Memoir. Archuleta admitted that learning to appreciate his own voice, both literally and figuratively, has been a lifelong process. “I’ve learned to love myself,” he shared, explaining that much of the memoir is about discovering personal worth and learning to appreciate what we contribute to the world.
Ansari cleverly incorporated Goodreads reviews into the conversation, including one particularly amusing observation from a longtime fan: “‘Crush’ went triple platinum in my bedroom in 2008. And now I get to display his memoir on the bookshelf in my living room in 2026.” Archuleta laughed about how fans still associate him with their teenage years, including young men who have since told him he was part of their Queer awakening. For someone who was struggling to understand his own sexuality at the time, the realization that he was unknowingly providing representation for others was especially touching.
Upbringing
The conversation turned more serious when Archuleta discussed his upbringing in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and the enormous pressure he faced to be the perfect Mormon role model. He described how church leaders and family expectations shaped his identity, often leaving him feeling that his own happiness was secondary to pleasing others.
In one of the evening’s most revealing moments, Archuleta recalled being encouraged to keep his relationships with men private while maintaining the appearance of a faithful church member. That contradiction ultimately helped him recognize that living honestly was more important than preserving an image.
Archuleta also spoke candidly about his complicated relationship with his father, who played a significant role in managing his early career. Writing about that relationship, he explained, allowed him to reclaim control over his own story. He credited fellow actress and author Jennette McCurdy, whose bestselling memoir I’m Glad My Mom Died inspired him to confront difficult family experiences, with encouraging him to write Devout. Unlike his earlier memoir, Archuleta was determined to tell this story in his own words, without a ghostwriter.
Life lessons
One of the evening’s most emotional discussions centered on his decision to come out publicly in 2021. Archuleta revealed that he had reached a devastating emotional low, struggling with suicidal thoughts as he attempted to reconcile his sexuality with his religious beliefs. Ultimately, he realized that accepting himself was essential to surviving. “What if I gave myself a second chance?” he recalled asking himself.
That second chance meant embracing his identity as a Queer man and allowing himself to experience love without shame. He also learned that disappointing people is sometimes an unavoidable part of becoming your authentic self. As he put it, he is still learning how to give himself permission to make mistakes.
For Archuleta, the memoir isn’t intended simply as a criticism of Mormonism. Rather, it is an invitation for religious communities to listen to LGBTQ+ people whose experiences have too often been dismissed. He challenged church leaders to read the book and better understand the emotional consequences of teachings that make Queer people feel unwelcome. Ansari, who shared her own experience growing up Muslim and coming out to a loving grandmother, emphasized the importance of compassion and acceptance across religious traditions.
Journey to authenticity
The evening wasn’t without lighter moments. Archuleta joked about his early career, admitted that he didn’t actually write his signature hit, “Crush,” and reflected on how much his relationship with music has changed. He also discussed reconnecting with his Latin heritage.
During the audience Q&A, fans asked about everything from his experiences performing in the Philippines to his early recordings and the possibility of returning to Seattle for a concert. One fan even questioned why the city had been left off his holiday tour. Archuleta explained that tour routing can be complicated but assured the audience he plans to return.
Another attendee, a choir director, asked for vocal warm-up advice, prompting an impromptu demonstration of singing exercises. It was a wonderfully appropriate ending to an evening about finding your voice, complete with a few intentional vocal cracks.
As the conversation concluded and fans prepared to have their books signed, what stood out most was how comfortable Archuleta appeared sharing both his triumphs and imperfections. The shy teenager who once seemed determined to please everyone has become a confident, thoughtful, and occasionally delightfully sassy adult who no longer feels obligated to fit anyone else’s expectations.
When I interviewed Archuleta last March, he emphasized that Devout was written to encourage greater inclusion of LGBTQ+ people within religious communities. Seeing him bring that message to a sold-out Seattle audience reinforced just how important his story has become. His journey isn’t simply about leaving a church or coming out. It’s about learning that faith, family, fame, and love should never require someone to sacrifice their identity.
And perhaps that was the evening’s most meaningful takeaway: David Archuleta spent years trying to become the person everyone wanted him to be. Now, at last, he’s discovering the joy of simply being David.
Support the Seattle Gay News: Celebrate 52 Years with Us!
As the third-oldest LGBTQIA+ newspaper in the United States, the Seattle Gay News (SGN) has been a vital independent source of news and entertainment for Seattle and the Pacific Northwest since 1974.
As we celebrate our 52nd year, we need your support to continue our mission.
A monthly contribution will ensure that SGN remains a beacon of truth and a virtual gathering place for community dialogue.
Help us keep printing and providing a platform for LGBTQIA+ voices.
How you can donate!
Using this link: givebutter.com/6lZnDB
Text “SGN” to 53-555
Or Scan the QR code below!

